11 Lipsticks With 1,000+ Five-Star Reviews at Sephora
My AccountFIND A DOCTORNewsCelebrityNew LaunchesTreatment & FDA NewsIndustry & Retail NewsFaceAcneAnti-AgingCelebrityEye CareHyperpigmentationMakeupSensitive SkinSkin CareSkin ConditionsSmileSun CareTreatmentsNeurotoxinsFillersLasers & Energy DevicesMicroneedlingPost-Procedure Skin CareRegenerative AestheticsSkin Lifting and TighteningBodySkin CareBody SculptingBreastsButtsCelluliteFragranceHands + NailsLegsPregnancyHairBond RepairCelebrity HairDry HairFrizzy HairGray HairHair ColorHair GrowthHair RepairScalp HealthTips + TutorialsAwardsNB100 Awards16th Annual Beauty Awards2025 NewBeauty Readers’ Choice AwardsShoppingBeautyReportGift GuidesNewBeauty StorefrontProduct ReviewsWellnessFitnessGLP-1sHealthMenopauseBEAUTYPASSNewsView All NewsCelebrityNew LaunchesTreatment & FDA NewsIndustry & Retail NewsFaceView All FaceAcneAnti-AgingCelebrityEye CareHyperpigmentationMakeupSensitive SkinSkin CareSkin ConditionsSmileSun CareTreatmentsView All TreatmentsNeurotoxinsFillersLasers & Energy DevicesMicroneedlingPost-Procedure Skin CareRegenerative AestheticsSkin Lifting and TighteningBodyView All BodySkin CareBody SculptingBreastsButtsCelluliteFragranceHands + NailsLegsPregnancyHairView All HairBond RepairCelebrity HairDry HairFrizzy HairGray HairHair ColorHair GrowthHair RepairScalp HealthTips + TutorialsAwardsView All AwardsNB100 Awards16th Annual Beauty Awards2025 NewBeauty Readers’ Choice AwardsShoppingView All ShoppingBeautyReportGift GuidesNewBeauty StorefrontProduct ReviewsWellnessView All WellnessFitnessGLP-1sHealthMenopauseLoading…FIND A DOCTORBEAUTYPASS Advertisement Home›Shopping›Product Reviews 11 Lipsticks With 1,000+ Five-Star Reviews at Sephora Believe the hype. Marisa PetrarcaInstagramAbout NewBeauty Sep 3, 2026
We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors. The best lipstick of all time is, of course, a matter of personal preference. For some, it’s a bold red lipstick; for others, a your-lips-but-better nude. But being subjective doesn't discredit the thousands of five-star reviews many of these lipsticks have at Sephora. I’m always wary of pushing readers toward only the best-sellers (niche brands can be just as good!), but the truth is, many fan favorites really do live up to the hype.