10 Mascaras With 1,000+ Five-Star Reviews at Sephora
NewBeauty Facebook Pinterest Instagram Youtube find a doctor Face Adult Acne Antioxidants Anti-Aging Celebrity Chronic Skin Conditions Eye Hydration Hyperpigmentation Makeup View All Eyebrows Eye Color Foundation Fragrance Lip Color Makeovers Male Skin Care Peels Pre-Event Prep Sensitive Skin Skin Care Skin Health Smile Sun Care Treatments Fillers Microneedling Post-Procedure Skin Care Neurotoxins Regenerative Aesthetics Skin Lifting Body Body Sculpting Breasts Butts Cellulite Hair Removal Hands + Nails Legs Pregnancy Find a Doctor Hair Bond Repair Celebrity Dry Hair Frizzy Hair Gray Hair Hair Color Hair Growth Hair Repair Scalp Health Styling + Tips Awards NB100 Awards 15th Annual Beauty Awards 2025 NewBeauty Readers’ Choice Awards Shopping Gift Guides Product Reviews NewBeauty Storefront Wellness Fitness GLP-1s Health Menopause About Us TESTTUBE Search for: Search HomeShopping 10 Mascaras With 1,000+ Five-Star Reviews at Sephora The top-rated tubes beauty lovers keep coming back to. By Hana Hong Published: Mar 6, 2026 We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors. Getty Images Mascara is one of those beauty products that’s hard to compromise on. Once you find a formula that delivers the right balance of volume, length and staying power, it tends to earn a permanent spot in your makeup bag. The problem is that getting there often involves testing countless tubes that end up smudging, flaking or clumping by midday. That’s where Sephora reviews can be surprisingly helpful. When a mascara collects thousands of five-star ratings, it usually means the formula has genuinely earned its reputation, whether it’s for creating dramatic, false-lash-level volume, holding a curl from morning to night or staying smooth and flake-free through a full day of wear. Some of these mascaras have gone viral for their ability to transform lashes in a single coat, while others…