11 Eyeshadows With 1,000+ Five-Star Reviews at Sephora
My AccountFIND A DOCTORNewsCelebrityNew LaunchesTreatment & FDA NewsIndustry & Retail NewsFaceAcneAnti-AgingCelebrityEye CareHyperpigmentationMakeupSensitive SkinSkin CareSmileSun CareTreatmentsNeurotoxinsFillersLasers & Energy DevicesMicroneedlingPost-Procedure Skin CareRegenerative AestheticsSkin ConditionsSkin Lifting and TighteningBodySkin CareBody SculptingBreastsButtsCelluliteFragranceHands + NailsLegsPregnancyHairBond RepairCelebrity HairDry HairFrizzy HairGray HairHair ColorHair GrowthHair RepairScalp HealthTips + TutorialsAwardsNB100 Awards16th Annual Beauty Awards2026 NewBeauty Readers’ Choice AwardsShoppingBeautyReportGift GuidesNewBeauty StorefrontProduct ReviewsWellnessFitnessGLP-1sHealthMenopauseNewBeauty RXBEAUTYPASSNewsView All NewsCelebrityNew LaunchesTreatment & FDA NewsIndustry & Retail NewsFaceView All FaceAcneAnti-AgingCelebrityEye CareHyperpigmentationMakeupSensitive SkinSkin CareSmileSun CareTreatmentsView All TreatmentsNeurotoxinsFillersLasers & Energy DevicesMicroneedlingPost-Procedure Skin CareRegenerative AestheticsSkin ConditionsSkin Lifting and TighteningBodyView All BodySkin CareBody SculptingBreastsButtsCelluliteFragranceHands + NailsLegsPregnancyHairView All HairBond RepairCelebrity HairDry HairFrizzy HairGray HairHair ColorHair GrowthHair RepairScalp HealthTips + TutorialsAwardsView All AwardsNB100 Awards16th Annual Beauty Awards2026 NewBeauty Readers’ Choice AwardsShoppingView All ShoppingBeautyReportGift GuidesNewBeauty StorefrontProduct ReviewsWellnessView All WellnessFitnessGLP-1sHealthMenopauseNewBeauty RXLoading…FIND A DOCTORBEAUTYPASS Advertisement Home›Face›Makeup 11 Eyeshadows With 1,000+ Five-Star Reviews at Sephora The cult classics shoppers (and NewBeauty editors) keep coming back to. Marisa PetrarcaInstagramAbout NewBeauty Oct 8, 2026
We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors. Looking for the best eyeshadow at Sephora? There’s no single answer. (Sorry!) It depends on who you ask. A makeup minimalist might get by on one pot of neutral cream shadow. A maximalist might not leave the house without a palette of a dozen shimmers and mattes. Either way, Sephora has options for both, and it’s where I usually start my search. I’m guessing I’m not alone.